|
Post by Ryan Aiken on May 23, 2010 11:08:19 GMT -5
Congrats you 3 on making it to the end! You all deserve to be in the finals no matter what any of these people say. Ive decided if this game would have actually been the real show it would no doubt be the best season of survivor lol. My questions are:
1) Compare each member of the jury to a real survivor and say why.
2) Rank the jury 1-8 based on overall gameplay and give one good and bad trait to each.
Good luck ;D
|
|
|
Post by Lex van den Berghe on May 25, 2010 0:40:02 GMT -5
1) Compare each member of the jury to a real survivor and say why.
I'll try to keep this somewhat current, but some seasons of the show stick out more than others to me so I'm more likely to use them...
1. Tina - Sierra (Tocantins) - For whatever reason, everyone seemed to be against her.
2. Sandra - Tyson (Tocantins) - Had a lot of potential, but taken out pretty early. Although Sandra's had a lot to do with game circumstances.
3. Vee - Burton (Pearl Islands) - Not just because of the Outcast twist, but also for being a threat who had a prime opportunity to make a long run in the game had things worked out a little bit differently.
4. Rob - Mick (Samoa) - A successful player, but overall pretty loyal, reserved and quiet who wasn't a dominant player but still wasn't a pushover by any means.
5. Peih-Gee - T-Bird (Africa) - Well-liked by both sides and probably had an opportunity to advance to a certain point with either.
6. Nicole - Elisabeth (Outback) - An extremely likeable, yet loyal player who made it deep into the game despite the odds being against her.
7. Ryan - Rob C (Amazon) - Went deep into the game with the ladies, but overall a very friendly and likeable person with a natural ability to play the game well.
8. Brendan - Keith (Outback) - He was kept around as an extra vote in an alliance until the end, he wasn't particularly good late in the game in challenges, and his alliance mates for the most part gave me the impression that they didn't really connect with him that well.
2) Rank the jury 1-8 based on overall gameplay and give one good and bad trait to each.
1. Ryan - You were friendly and easy to talk to, and you were a good at hiding your sneakiness. A weakness was that you were so locked into your alliance that it put a huge target on your back and that's hard to play with.
2. Peih-Gee - I thought Peih-Gee had a really good opportunity in this game as well. The Posting Challenge twist did her in...I'm not sure if she would have made it deep into the game, but I feel like had Ryan/Jaime happened to lose the posting challenge, the game could have been wide open again. Peih-Gee impressed me with her gameplay after Vee was voted out the first time, she fought hard and stood up for herself and kept going in the game long into the merge.
3. Sandra - Sandra is the one mystery player that I would've loved to have seen a lot more from. I feel like she had a lot more game left to play when she was taken out. I was always impressed by her stone cold poker face, but I think that can also be seen as a negative in that she was hard to crack.
4. Nicole - Nicole was a great ally and someone who I'm glad I had a second chance to play with because in Spratly we worked together but we didn't talk nearly as much. It was disappointing to lose Mike so soon in the game, so I'm glad I had someone else that lasted deep into the game as well that I could bounce ideas off of. I think Nicole's only real weakness (besides falling on the wrong side of the numbers) was that she was still pretty reserved and held back in the challenges.
5. Rob - Rob is a loyal player and someone who's easy to get along with as far as bouncing ideas off goes. I think he was a little too quiet in the game this time, and I sometimes wish I had gotten more of a chance to talk to him and brainstorm some, and that is sometimes hard to do by PM.
6. Vee - Vee had a golden opportunity in this game and I think she knows that and I think she knows where her mistake was. She's a very strong and capable player, and I came to respect her quickly from day one. If I had to criticize her gameplay, I would say she was a little too aggressive with some of her plans and it made some people feel threatened.
7. Tina - I know for a fact that Tina had a lot more game left in her, and she was a strong and loyal player to me while she was around. I think Tina got a late start in this game which hurt her, as well as a little attitude that she showed to Vee that unfortunately ended up sealing her fate.
8. Brendan - I can't respect someone who didn't submit half the challenges, didn't bother to talk to anyone that he wasn't allied with, and napped his way through the game while riding on your coattails. I guess he picked the right coattails to ride, though.
|
|
|
Post by Jaime Dugan♥ on May 25, 2010 1:15:27 GMT -5
Tina-Christa Hastie-like Christa, Tina had conflict within her tribes which lead to her being voted out. I am basing this on what I knew of Tina in the game.
Sandra-Cirie Fields-A likable person, I was never sure what side she would end up on, which made her a good strategist.
Vee-Burton Roberts-Good at challenges, strong willed, intelligent, and an outcast brought back into the game
Boston Rob-Mick Trimming-He was laid back, quiet, and aligned with a power player in the game as Mick was with Russell
Peih Gee-Sugar Kiper, one of my favorites. Like Sugar, Peih Gee spend time in exile, she worked with both alliances and voted out her ally, Vee as Sugar did with Ace & Matty.
Nicole-Alexis Jones-Likable, laid back, wanted a strong female alliance.
Brendan-Ian Rosenberger-He was quiet, loyal, and sacrificed himself for his allies and friends. Brendan was the same and would have done the same despite me disagreeing.
Ryan-Yul Kwon-Smart, strategic and social when he wants to be
Ryan-You are strategic, always thinking ahead, loyal and trustworthy. You can tend to get cocky and comfortable, though that side didn't really come out.
Nicole-Likable and friendly, a great and loyal ally. Hard to wonder what she are thinking at times, she just tends to agree.
Sandra-Fun and likable, I always enjoy my conversations with her, I was just never sure where I stood with her 100%.
Peih Gee-Laid back and easy going from the communication I had with her, played a big part in this game, downside hard to communicate will only through PM.
Boston Rob-I enjoyed talking to Rob as well, loyal if you are on his side, I find him hard to communicate with as well and make plans with due to PMs.
Vee-She is straightforward and to the point, I always felt I knew where she was coming from. From what I saw on the outside looking in she seemed to clash and people felt she was trying to control them.
Brendan-He is one of the most loyal and trustworthy people I know, I always know where I stand with him, he is too selfless at times not putting himself first.
Tina-I am basing this on what I know of Tina, she is a loyal player to the end, she can tend to be impatient at times.
Thanks Ryan!
|
|